START OF 2024: MAGIC, MYTHOLOGY AND MANSIONS.

 

  1. The Books of Magic by Neil Gaiman. 4.5

I tried to read this graphic novel many years ago when I got it out of a library, but I didn't get into it then. Neil Gaiman is my favourite author, and this book seemed like a glaring omission from my collection, one I felt deserved another go- and the title seemed perfect for the first book for me to read- as I hope to discover a world of magical books.

The story of Timothy Hunter, a reluctant 13-year-old magician, is as lyrical and as entertaining as anything else Gaiman has written- the esoteric knowledge is all there, and the inclusion of other DC comics magic-wielders cleverly handled. According to the introduction, it follows the archetypal heroic quest story (as described in Joseph Campbell's Hero with a Thousand Faces) very closely. Much has been made about the similarities between Timothy and Harry Potter, who debuted seven years later. But it is no more than a coincidence that both boys wear glasses and have a pet owl (at least Hedwig is a real owl, not an enchanted yoyo). It reminded me much more of A Christmas Carol, the mysterious men in trenchcoats replacing the traditional Dickens ghosts, each taking Timothy into another realm- past, present, Faerie and future.

I was stunned by how eerily familiar some images seemed: John Bolton's neolithic shaman and gambolling Pan, Charles Vess' glorious goblin market. It was like discovering your dreams in print. I have knocked off half a star, purely for the final chapter's artwork by Paul Johnson, which is more chaotic and harder to follow than the proceeding chapters. The book feels like the beginning of something - (and indeed, the series has continued in the hands of other writers) -and hopefully, it's the start of many more books to read and enjoy this year! :)

  1. Circe by Madeline Miller.  5


A few months ago, I read Stone Blind by Natalie Haynes, a retelling of the Medusa story. It was a pleasant enough read, but it felt lacking somehow. But this is the real deal: Greek Mythology, vividly and convincingly told. I knew very little of Circe before reading this novel. All I knew was that she turned sailors into pigs, and there was a beautiful John William Waterhouse painting of her. 


Despite it being the story of a witch goddess who has a lion as a familiar, Circe comes across as a very human, believable character. The childbirth scene, the sensitively handled scene with the drunk sailor captain, and the emotions she has for her lovers and those who try to thwart her are raw and realistic. 


Most convincing is the fear for her son - what do the Fates have lined up for him when she has made herself some very powerful enemies? All the characters are flawed and have difficult decisions to make, and consequences to face, but the emotions behind them and the way they handle the situations are convincing. Madeline Miller has weaved a spellbinding novel, well-deserving of the full five stars. It’s given me a hunger for the ancient world, and I don’t think it’ll be too long before I read another Greek mythology-based novel. 


  1. The Atlas Paradox by Olivie Blake  0.5 DNF


I purchased this whilst I was starting the Atlas Six, which started well ( if VERY similar to the Umbrella Academy )… and then… nothing happened… and more nothing happened. All of the characters are pretty much identical and unlikable. They spend a long time being unpleasant about each other, pretending to sound intelligent and speaking in unrealistic, awkwardly constructed sentences. You get a vague idea that there should be lessons and stuff going on in this supposed place of learning, but we aren’t privy to any of that.  We don’t learn anything of what goes on there. Imagine you have the world of Harry Potter, and all the magic spells are happening as usual but the entire book is just students gossiping in the Slytherin Common room and not making any discernible sense. It’s a very gruelling read. Then, just as something happens, it all stops.  It didn’t make me excited to read on. I was just annoyed that the book didn’t come to any satisfactory kind of ending. 


I couldn’t do it. I will try again another time as I didn’t like to abandon books mid-read, but goodness me, it’s a hell of a slog. Deathly!


  1. The Study in Drowning by Ava Reid 5


Anything I tried to read after The Atlas Complex would probably get five stars.  But this one is a corker. It’s a love story and a mystery with a Faerie King.  What more do you need to know? I have no clue when or where it’s supposed to take place-  I think it’s in a sort of Wales in a parallel universe, with a north/ south divide. It takes place in the early 200s but seems modern otherwise.  It doesn’t matter, but I’m not sure why the writer chose it to be ambiguous. The only other quibble I had with it was that so many of the older men in the book were horrible and lascivious and desired young girls half their age. There is a good reason for that, but it was an awkward read at times.  But these are minor issues. The five stars are well deserved.


Effy and Preston are adorable characters; the drowning house on a cliff is beautifully gothic and dilapidated, and Effy’s treasured book, the Angharad feels like it has a life far outside of the pages of this book. It was a real page-turner, and it did not disappoint. It did not try to explain away all the supernatural elements of the story, and the ending was very satisfying. Ava Reid is a strong writer who knows how stories should work. Olivie Blake, take note.

Comments